MaxCut, arbitrary graph: which simulator is fastest

QAOA over a random-edge graph

8 simulators ran this circuit at 4 to 24 qubits, 16 workloads in all. Qulacs was the fastest in 9, Google qsim in 6 and PennyLane Lightning in 1. The tables below hold every time as it was measured, with the fastest in each row marked. Open this circuit in the interactive tool to see the hardware that could run it and what a run would cost.

Expectation value, local observable, depth 3

Time per run, by qubit count

QubitsPennyLanePennyLane LightningQiskitQiskit AerQiskit Aer (MPS)Google qsimQulacsTensorCircuit
4 qubits
PennyLane
6.19 ms
PennyLane Lightning
3.28 ms
Qiskit
2.23 ms
Qiskit Aer
1.76 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
2.13 ms
Google qsim
2.89 ms
Qulacs
71.4 µs
TensorCircuit
error
8 qubits
PennyLane
14.4 ms
PennyLane Lightning
6.53 ms
Qiskit
5.90 ms
Qiskit Aer
3.41 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
5.01 ms
Google qsim
5.89 ms
Qulacs
188 µs
TensorCircuit
error
12 qubits
PennyLane
28.0 ms
PennyLane Lightning
10.8 ms
Qiskit
15.3 ms
Qiskit Aer
8.53 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
192 ms
Google qsim
9.80 ms
Qulacs
1.51 ms
TensorCircuit
error
16 qubits
PennyLane
115 ms
PennyLane Lightning
18.6 ms
Qiskit
150 ms
Qiskit Aer
36.5 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
4.03 s
Google qsim
12.7 ms
Qulacs
25.8 ms
TensorCircuit
error
20 qubits
PennyLane
2.79 s
PennyLane Lightning
258 ms
Qiskit
4.43 s
Qiskit Aer
678 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
skip
Google qsim
65.3 ms
Qulacs
588 ms
TensorCircuit
error
24 qubits
PennyLane
skip
PennyLane Lightning
9.47 s
Qiskit
skip
Qiskit Aer
13.8 s
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
skip
Google qsim
2.04 s
Qulacs
16.1 s
TensorCircuit
error

Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3

Time per run, by qubit count

QubitsPennyLanePennyLane LightningQiskitQiskit AerQiskit Aer (MPS)Google qsimQulacsTensorCircuit
4 qubits
PennyLane
6.57 ms
PennyLane Lightning
3.46 ms
Qiskit
2.40 ms
Qiskit Aer
1.83 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
2.22 ms
Google qsim
2.95 ms
Qulacs
81.0 µs
TensorCircuit
error
8 qubits
PennyLane
15.4 ms
PennyLane Lightning
6.83 ms
Qiskit
6.21 ms
Qiskit Aer
3.68 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
5.54 ms
Google qsim
6.17 ms
Qulacs
239 µs
TensorCircuit
error
12 qubits
PennyLane
30.3 ms
PennyLane Lightning
11.4 ms
Qiskit
15.9 ms
Qiskit Aer
9.34 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
208 ms
Google qsim
10.0 ms
Qulacs
2.39 ms
TensorCircuit
error
16 qubits
PennyLane
126 ms
PennyLane Lightning
23.0 ms
Qiskit
150 ms
Qiskit Aer
45.3 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
5.23 s
Google qsim
13.8 ms
Qulacs
46.3 ms
TensorCircuit
error
20 qubits
PennyLane
3.07 s
PennyLane Lightning
366 ms
Qiskit
4.30 s
Qiskit Aer
820 ms
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
timeout
Google qsim
79.9 ms
Qulacs
1.00 s
TensorCircuit
error
24 qubits
PennyLane
skip
PennyLane Lightning
15.3 s
Qiskit
skip
Qiskit Aer
16.7 s
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
skip
Google qsim
2.44 s
Qulacs
24.2 s
TensorCircuit
error

Gradient, local observable, depth 3

Time per run, by qubit count

QubitsPennyLanePennyLane LightningQiskitQiskit AerQiskit Aer (MPS)Google qsimQulacsTensorCircuit
4 qubits
PennyLane
26.9 ms
PennyLane Lightning
6.49 ms
Qiskit
unsupported
Qiskit Aer
unsupported
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
unsupported
Google qsim
unsupported
Qulacs
287 µs
TensorCircuit
error
8 qubits
PennyLane
63.3 ms
PennyLane Lightning
12.6 ms
Qiskit
unsupported
Qiskit Aer
unsupported
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
unsupported
Google qsim
unsupported
Qulacs
873 µs
TensorCircuit
error
12 qubits
PennyLane
170 ms
PennyLane Lightning
21.5 ms
Qiskit
unsupported
Qiskit Aer
unsupported
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
unsupported
Google qsim
unsupported
Qulacs
8.07 ms
TensorCircuit
error
16 qubits
PennyLane
1.08 s
PennyLane Lightning
77.4 ms
Qiskit
unsupported
Qiskit Aer
unsupported
Qiskit Aer (MPS)
unsupported
Google qsim
unsupported
Qulacs
148 ms
TensorCircuit
error

Which quantum computers can run it

At depth 3, 1,000 shots

Quantum computerCan run it up toBorderline up toEstimated cost at that size
Can run it up to
4 qubits
Borderline up to
32 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
$200.30–$600.90
via AWS Braket
Can run it up to
16 qubits
Borderline up to
32 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
$200.30–$600.90
via AWS Braket
Can run it up to
4 qubits
Borderline up to
12 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
$23.80–$71.40
via AWS Braket
Can run it up to
64 qubits
Borderline up to
96 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
Not priced
this vendor publishes no rate card
Can run it up to
48 qubits
Borderline up to
–
Estimated cost at that size
Not priced
this vendor publishes no rate card
Can run it up to
48 qubits
Borderline up to
–
Estimated cost at that size
Not priced
this vendor publishes no rate card
Can run it up to
–
Borderline up to
–
Estimated cost at that size
–
Can run it up to
–
Borderline up to
–
Estimated cost at that size
–
Can run it up to
–
Borderline up to
–
Estimated cost at that size
–
Can run it up to
12 qubits
Borderline up to
48 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
from $0.015
via IBM Quantum. 0.01s at maximum throughput, so this is a floor
Can run it up to
8 qubits
Borderline up to
48 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
from $0.421
via IBM Quantum. 0.26s at maximum throughput, so this is a floor
Can run it up to
8 qubits
Borderline up to
32 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
from $0.421
via IBM Quantum. 0.26s at maximum throughput, so this is a floor
Can run it up to
–
Borderline up to
12 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
$0.725–$2.17
via AWS Braket
Can run it up to
8 qubits
Borderline up to
32 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
$1.90–$5.70
via AWS Braket
Can run it up to
4 qubits
Borderline up to
20 qubits
Estimated cost at that size
$1.75–$5.25
via AWS Braket

Sizes are the grid's own: 4, 8, 12, 16, 20, 24, 32, 48, 64, 96, 128, 156 qubits. A device can run a circuit when a clean run is more likely than not, and is borderline when it is better than one in fifty. The cost is for one run of 1,000 shots at the largest size in the row, as a band and not a quote.

The simulators

Each one across every circuit family

How this was measured

One host, one harness

Every simulator ran the same circuits on one host, single-threaded and core-pinned, driven through one common harness, so any overhead the harness adds is charged to the simulator. Each result was checked against a reference implementation: a simulator that ran fast but returned the wrong answer is left out of the ranking. Nothing is interpolated or rescaled. A time was measured, or it is not shown.

Run 2026-08-10, 8 cores, threads=1. numpy 2.4.6, scipy 1.18.0, torch 2.13.0, numba 0.66.0, pennylane 0.45.1, pennylane_lightning 0.45.0, qiskit 2.5.1, qulacs 0.6.14, tensorcircuit 1.8.0, cudaq 0.15.1. One host and one thread make the comparison reproducible. It is not a prediction for your laptop.

The interactive tool shows the same measurements for any workload you pick, with the quantum hardware that could run it and what a run would cost.

Hardware figures each carry the source they came from and the date they were measured. The oldest in this set is 626 days old. Costs are bands, not quotes.

Host: Linux-6.8.0-1051-aws-x86_64-with-glibc2.35, 8 cores, threads=1, core-pinned. numpy 2.4.6, scipy 1.18.0, torch 2.13.0, numba 0.66.0, pennylane 0.45.1, pennylane_lightning 0.45.0. Every simulator was driven through one common harness, so any harness binding overhead is charged to the simulator rather than hidden.

© 2026 EigenOrbit. All rights reserved.