PennyLane Lightning vs Qulacs
The same circuits, one host
PennyLane Lightning and Qulacs both finished 166 of the 175 workloads measured here. PennyLane Lightning was faster in 71 of them and Qulacs in 95. At the median Qulacs was 2.6× faster.
By circuit family
Who was faster where
| Circuit family | Workloads both finished | PennyLane Lightning faster in | Qulacs faster in | Faster at the median |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Workloads both finished 16 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 7 | Qulacs faster in 9 | Faster at the median Qulacs 2.4× | |
| Workloads both finished 24 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 11 | Qulacs faster in 13 | Faster at the median Qulacs 3.8× | |
| Workloads both finished 27 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 12 | Qulacs faster in 15 | Faster at the median Qulacs 3.2× | |
| Workloads both finished 16 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 7 | Qulacs faster in 9 | Faster at the median Qulacs 3.7× | |
| Workloads both finished 24 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 11 | Qulacs faster in 13 | Faster at the median Qulacs 3.1× | |
| Workloads both finished 12 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 4 | Qulacs faster in 8 | Faster at the median Qulacs 2.4× | |
| Workloads both finished 19 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 8 | Qulacs faster in 11 | Faster at the median Qulacs 2.8× | |
| Workloads both finished 16 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 7 | Qulacs faster in 9 | Faster at the median Qulacs 2.2× | |
| Workloads both finished 12 | PennyLane Lightning faster in 4 | Qulacs faster in 8 | Faster at the median Qulacs 1.3× |
Local circuit dynamics
Brickwork nearest-neighbour layers: lattice models, quench dynamics
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 1.48 ms | Qulacs 32.1 µs | Faster Qulacs 46.0× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 2.18 ms | Qulacs 73.1 µs | Faster Qulacs 29.8× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 2.88 ms | Qulacs 585 µs | Faster Qulacs 4.9× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 5.58 ms | Qulacs 10.7 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 66.6 ms | Qulacs 206 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.1× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 2.46 s | Qulacs 4.76 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 1.70 ms | Qulacs 42.5 µs | Faster Qulacs 40.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 2.50 ms | Qulacs 119 µs | Faster Qulacs 21.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 3.49 ms | Qulacs 1.38 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 9.80 ms | Qulacs 26.2 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.7× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 177 ms | Qulacs 535 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 8.20 s | Qulacs 10.7 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.3× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 3.25 ms | Qulacs 117 µs | Faster Qulacs 27.7× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 4.77 ms | Qulacs 307 µs | Faster Qulacs 15.5× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 6.94 ms | Qulacs 3.00 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.3× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 27.7 ms | Qulacs 59.6 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.2× |
Hamiltonian time evolution
Trotterised spin chain: ZZ + XX couplings with local fields
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 4.43 ms | Qulacs 104 µs | Faster Qulacs 42.5× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 9.09 ms | Qulacs 276 µs | Faster Qulacs 33.0× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 14.5 ms | Qulacs 1.85 ms | Faster Qulacs 7.8× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 32.9 ms | Qulacs 34.0 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.0× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 444 ms | Qulacs 711 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.6× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 16.1 s | Qulacs 21.1 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 4.63 ms | Qulacs 113 µs | Faster Qulacs 41.1× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 9.47 ms | Qulacs 321 µs | Faster Qulacs 29.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 14.9 ms | Qulacs 2.51 ms | Faster Qulacs 5.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 37.6 ms | Qulacs 48.2 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 563 ms | Qulacs 1.02 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 21.9 s | Qulacs 26.9 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.2× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 9.63 ms | Qulacs 349 µs | Faster Qulacs 27.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 15.2 ms | Qulacs 3.17 ms | Faster Qulacs 4.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 45.6 ms | Qulacs 61.5 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 795 ms | Qulacs 1.28 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 9.40 ms | Qulacs 305 µs | Faster Qulacs 30.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 14.8 ms | Qulacs 2.50 ms | Faster Qulacs 5.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 38.4 ms | Qulacs 48.1 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 588 ms | Qulacs 1.01 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.7× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 8.08 ms | Qulacs 424 µs | Faster Qulacs 19.1× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 15.9 ms | Qulacs 1.17 ms | Faster Qulacs 13.5× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 26.4 ms | Qulacs 9.19 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.9× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 116 ms | Qulacs 181 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.6× |
MaxCut on a ring
QAOA over a cycle graph
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 2.84 ms | Qulacs 63.1 µs | Faster Qulacs 44.9× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 4.94 ms | Qulacs 154 µs | Faster Qulacs 32.1× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 6.97 ms | Qulacs 1.14 ms | Faster Qulacs 6.1× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 14.2 ms | Qulacs 20.9 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.5× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 176 ms | Qulacs 433 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.5× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 6.43 s | Qulacs 10.6 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.7× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 3.02 ms | Qulacs 72.0 µs | Faster Qulacs 41.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.23 ms | Qulacs 197 µs | Faster Qulacs 26.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 7.65 ms | Qulacs 1.91 ms | Faster Qulacs 4.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 18.2 ms | Qulacs 36.9 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 285 ms | Qulacs 740 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 12.2 s | Qulacs 16.6 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.4× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.59 ms | Qulacs 234 µs | Faster Qulacs 23.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 8.47 ms | Qulacs 2.61 ms | Faster Qulacs 3.2× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 27.1 ms | Qulacs 52.1 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 543 ms | Qulacs 1.03 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.43 ms | Qulacs 191 µs | Faster Qulacs 28.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 7.92 ms | Qulacs 1.95 ms | Faster Qulacs 4.1× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 20.6 ms | Qulacs 38.6 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 332 ms | Qulacs 762 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.3× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 5.73 ms | Qulacs 255 µs | Faster Qulacs 22.5× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 9.69 ms | Qulacs 681 µs | Faster Qulacs 14.2× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 14.9 ms | Qulacs 6.05 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.5× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 61.5 ms | Qulacs 120 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.0× |
Statevector, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 7.03 ms | Qulacs 155 µs | Faster Qulacs 45.3× |
Statevector, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 9.39 ms | Qulacs 1.13 ms | Faster Qulacs 8.3× |
Statevector, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 17.3 ms | Qulacs 21.0 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.2× |
MaxCut, arbitrary graph
QAOA over a random-edge graph
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 3.28 ms | Qulacs 71.4 µs | Faster Qulacs 45.9× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 6.53 ms | Qulacs 188 µs | Faster Qulacs 34.8× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 10.8 ms | Qulacs 1.51 ms | Faster Qulacs 7.1× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 18.6 ms | Qulacs 25.8 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.4× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 258 ms | Qulacs 588 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.3× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 9.47 s | Qulacs 16.1 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.7× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 3.46 ms | Qulacs 81.0 µs | Faster Qulacs 42.7× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 6.83 ms | Qulacs 239 µs | Faster Qulacs 28.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 11.4 ms | Qulacs 2.39 ms | Faster Qulacs 4.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 23.0 ms | Qulacs 46.3 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 366 ms | Qulacs 1.00 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.7× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 15.3 s | Qulacs 24.2 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.6× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 6.49 ms | Qulacs 287 µs | Faster Qulacs 22.6× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 12.6 ms | Qulacs 873 µs | Faster Qulacs 14.5× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 21.5 ms | Qulacs 8.07 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.7× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 77.4 ms | Qulacs 148 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Sampling / IQP
Diagonal phase circuit between Hadamard layers
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 2.97 ms | Qulacs 68.8 µs | Faster Qulacs 43.2× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.19 ms | Qulacs 156 µs | Faster Qulacs 33.3× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 7.50 ms | Qulacs 1.04 ms | Faster Qulacs 7.2× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 15.5 ms | Qulacs 18.5 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.2× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 206 ms | Qulacs 392 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 7.66 s | Qulacs 10.7 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.4× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 3.18 ms | Qulacs 78.2 µs | Faster Qulacs 40.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.57 ms | Qulacs 203 µs | Faster Qulacs 27.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 8.14 ms | Qulacs 1.97 ms | Faster Qulacs 4.1× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 20.3 ms | Qulacs 38.7 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 317 ms | Qulacs 797 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 13.6 s | Qulacs 19.1 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.4× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.87 ms | Qulacs 239 µs | Faster Qulacs 24.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 8.96 ms | Qulacs 2.67 ms | Faster Qulacs 3.4× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 28.1 ms | Qulacs 53.4 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (pauli_mix), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 566 ms | Qulacs 1.09 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.76 ms | Qulacs 196 µs | Faster Qulacs 29.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 8.48 ms | Qulacs 2.04 ms | Faster Qulacs 4.2× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 22.2 ms | Qulacs 39.9 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (zz_sum), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 363 ms | Qulacs 856 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.4× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 5.95 ms | Qulacs 272 µs | Faster Qulacs 21.8× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 10.1 ms | Qulacs 701 µs | Faster Qulacs 14.3× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 15.4 ms | Qulacs 5.38 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.9× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 65.3 ms | Qulacs 105 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.6× |
Quantum kernel feature map
Data-encoding circuit for kernel methods
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 4.26 ms | Qulacs 107 µs | Faster Qulacs 40.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 5.92 ms | Qulacs 895 µs | Faster Qulacs 6.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 12.9 ms | Qulacs 16.9 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 40.2 ms | Qulacs 3.36 ms | Faster Qulacs 12.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 66.1 ms | Qulacs 28.3 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 262 ms | Qulacs 539 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.1× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 301 ms | Qulacs 26.9 ms | Faster Qulacs 11.2× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 501 ms | Qulacs 226 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.2× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 2.19 s | Qulacs 4.31 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 1024 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 1.41 s | Qulacs 109 ms | Faster Qulacs 12.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 1024 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 2.25 s | Qulacs 915 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 1024 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 8.28 s | Qulacs 17.3 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.1× |
Hardware-efficient VQE
RY/RZ layers with a CNOT ring
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 2.18 ms | Qulacs 52.5 µs | Faster Qulacs 41.4× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 3.48 ms | Qulacs 126 µs | Faster Qulacs 27.5× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 4.96 ms | Qulacs 1.03 ms | Faster Qulacs 4.8× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 10.3 ms | Qulacs 19.2 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 136 ms | Qulacs 386 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.8× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 4.80 s | Qulacs 8.90 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.9× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 2.41 ms | Qulacs 63.7 µs | Faster Qulacs 37.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 3.81 ms | Qulacs 172 µs | Faster Qulacs 22.2× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 5.56 ms | Qulacs 1.97 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 14.5 ms | Qulacs 40.2 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 248 ms | Qulacs 808 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 10.6 s | Qulacs 17.1 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.6× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 4.69 ms | Qulacs 206 µs | Faster Qulacs 22.7× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 7.64 ms | Qulacs 577 µs | Faster Qulacs 13.2× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 11.5 ms | Qulacs 5.51 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.1× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 54.3 ms | Qulacs 110 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.0× |
Statevector, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.38 ms | Qulacs 129 µs | Faster Qulacs 41.7× |
Statevector, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 6.94 ms | Qulacs 1.00 ms | Faster Qulacs 6.9× |
Statevector, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 12.4 ms | Qulacs 18.9 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.5× |
Strongly-entangling ansatz
RX/RY/RZ layers with a CNOT ring
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 2.43 ms | Qulacs 68.2 µs | Faster Qulacs 35.6× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 4.09 ms | Qulacs 177 µs | Faster Qulacs 23.1× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 5.88 ms | Qulacs 1.56 ms | Faster Qulacs 3.8× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 13.1 ms | Qulacs 30.0 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.3× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 177 ms | Qulacs 595 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.4× |
Expectation value, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 6.45 s | Qulacs 13.2 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.1× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 2.65 ms | Qulacs 77.7 µs | Faster Qulacs 34.1× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 4.38 ms | Qulacs 222 µs | Faster Qulacs 19.7× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 6.44 ms | Qulacs 2.50 ms | Faster Qulacs 2.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 17.1 ms | Qulacs 50.6 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.0× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 20 | PennyLane Lightning 290 ms | Qulacs 1.02 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 3 | Qubits 24 | PennyLane Lightning 12.3 s | Qulacs 21.4 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 1.7× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 4 | PennyLane Lightning 5.82 ms | Qulacs 278 µs | Faster Qulacs 20.9× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 9.62 ms | Qulacs 822 µs | Faster Qulacs 11.7× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 15.2 ms | Qulacs 8.63 ms | Faster Qulacs 1.8× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 3 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 77.4 ms | Qulacs 180 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.3× |
Data re-uploading QML
Repeated encode-and-rotate classifier
| Workload | Qubits | PennyLane Lightning | Qulacs | Faster |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 5.31 ms | Qulacs 185 µs | Faster Qulacs 28.7× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 7.58 ms | Qulacs 2.06 ms | Faster Qulacs 3.7× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 17.0 ms | Qulacs 41.8 ms | Faster PennyLane Lightning 2.5× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 53.2 ms | Qulacs 6.97 ms | Faster Qulacs 7.6× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 88.0 ms | Qulacs 67.1 ms | Faster Qulacs 1.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 354 ms | Qulacs 1.33 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 398 ms | Qulacs 48.4 ms | Faster Qulacs 8.2× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 670 ms | Qulacs 529 ms | Faster Qulacs 1.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 2.81 s | Qulacs 10.6 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.8× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 1024 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning 1.80 s | Qulacs 193 ms | Faster Qulacs 9.3× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 1024 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning 2.91 s | Qulacs 2.13 s | Faster Qulacs 1.4× |
Expectation value, global observable (all_z), depth 2, batch of 1024 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning 11.3 s | Qulacs 42.7 s | Faster PennyLane Lightning 3.8× |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 606 µs | Faster – |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 5.81 ms | Faster – |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 117 ms | Faster – |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 19.3 ms | Faster – |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 189 ms | Faster – |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2, batch of 32 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 3.76 s | Faster – |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 8 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 153 ms | Faster – |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 12 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 1.47 s | Faster – |
Gradient, local observable, depth 2, batch of 256 | Qubits 16 | PennyLane Lightning unsupported | Qulacs 30.0 s | Faster – |
How this was measured
One host, one harness
Every simulator ran the same circuits on one host, single-threaded and core-pinned, driven through one common harness, so any overhead the harness adds is charged to the simulator. Each result was checked against a reference implementation: a simulator that ran fast but returned the wrong answer is left out of the ranking. Nothing is interpolated or rescaled. A time was measured, or it is not shown.
Run 2026-08-10, 8 cores, threads=1. numpy 2.4.6, scipy 1.18.0, torch 2.13.0, numba 0.66.0, pennylane 0.45.1, pennylane_lightning 0.45.0, qiskit 2.5.1, qulacs 0.6.14, tensorcircuit 1.8.0, cudaq 0.15.1. One host and one thread make the comparison reproducible. It is not a prediction for your laptop.
The interactive tool shows the same measurements for any workload you pick, with the quantum hardware that could run it and what a run would cost.